Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://zone.biblio.laurentian.ca/handle/10219/3394
Title: Evidence-based strategies in occupational health: applying meta-analytic and qualitative methods to identify and understand sickness absence among nurses and health care aides with considerations for Northeastern Ontario  
Authors: Gohar, Basem
Keywords: sickness absence;nurses;health care aides;meta-analysis;focus groups;thematic analysis
Issue Date: 17-Dec-2018
Abstract: Purpose: Compared to other employees, nurses and health care aides (HCAs) have the highest sickness absence rates in Canada yet the phenomenon remains insufficiently studied. Furthermore, the potential influence of geography on sickness absence has received scant attention. Guided by the Evidence-Based Practice in Occupational Health Psychology framework, this investigation aimed to identify factors associated with sickness absence, understand how they occur, and determine factors that may be specific to communities in northeastern Ontario. Methods: A systematic review identified relevant studies through structured search strategies, article screening, and quality testing. Pooled statistics in the form of odds ratios and confidence intervals were computed. Follow-up analyses examined heterogeneity (Q& I2). Qualitatively, focus group sessions were held with registered nurses (n= 6), registered practical nurses (n= 4), HCAs (n= 5), and key informants specialized in nursing, occupational health, disability management, and rehabilitation (n= 5). Nursing personnel were recruited from hospitals and long-term care facilities. Narrative data were analyzed using thematic analysis. Results: Meta-analytic searches yielded 812 studies, of which 27 met eligibility, and 11 variables that influenced the odds of sickness absence in a statistically significant manner (p< .05). Variables include: sex, occupation, health rating, previous sick leave, musculoskeletal pain, poor mental health, fatigue, night shifts, pediatric and psychiatric units, increased occupational demand, and work support. Poor health rating was highly heterogeneous (p< .05; I2= 82.77%). Thematic analysis revealed four primary themes: (1) Organizational factors including exposure to infectious diseases, shift work, safety climate, and work setting; (2) the jobs’ physical impact, mainly musculoskeletal pain; (3) psychological/mental impact including guilt, anxiety, and burnout; and (4) factors unique to northeastern Ontario including poor weather and road conditions, especially for HCAs providing home care, and the limited opportunity of interconnected health care networks where employers make staff available during worker shortages. Factors leading to sickness absence were described, with staff shortage serving as an important underlying contributor. Conclusion: This investigation points to the complexity and intricacy of factors influencing sickness absences. The qualitative results helped deepen the understanding of the quantitative findings, while considering northern-specific factors. Several concerns were attributed to staff shortages.
URI: https://zone.biblio.laurentian.ca/handle/10219/3394
Appears in Collections:Doctoral Theses
Doctoral theses

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
BGohar_PhDThesis Final.pdf4.02 MBAdobe PDFThumbnail
View/Open


Items in LU|ZONE|UL are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.